It Stinks Having Your Offer Turned Down

I recently toured an apartment. The agent showed me a couple units but didn’t get me into the ones I had planned to see. The property manager said that they forgot to give 24 hour notice. So, I was only able to see a couple of vacant units. These were in a state of disrepair and didn’t look like any work was being done to get them rent-ready. This was a big red flag. But red flags can sometimes mean $$ in value-add, so I made an offer.

Coming up with a price takes a lot of spreadsheeting and math, but in the end, there is an element of gut feeling about whether to buy or not. We try to limit this feeling, but it never goes away. If we ended up making the right choice, we call it intuition. If we made the wrong choice, we blame it as a mistake. Neither is quite correct.

I was left with the decision on whether to make an offer based on an assumption that all the rest of the units were in great condition as the seller was claiming, or to make an offer based on the units I had seen. I went with the latter, which resulted in $200,000 of repairs needed, and a big haircut for the seller. They turned me down. What might have happened if I did it the other way?

Coming Up With a Price

As stated, this is a difficult thing to do, with a lot of numbers and some subjectivity. Going completely with what the seller says would mean making an asking price offer, but that is not usually done. There is usually a lower price. This can be from several factors, like repairs, or estimating the market rent. It also might be that the seller knows the final price will be somewhere in the middle, so asks for a somewhat higher price. Either way, the buyer has to come up with a price that he can stomach, understanding that the seller might come back with a higher price. If the buyer’s offer is too far off, the seller might get insulted and just stop talking. One buyer strategy is to give an asking price offer with the plan to find a bunch of issues in diligence, and renegotiate at the end.

Renegotiation

This is when various issues are found on the diligence (either in the documents produced or inspection) and the buyer asks for a lower price based on these issues. If done in good faith, it is a normal part of the negotiation. If done with the expectation of getting a lower price, this is at best unethical, and is called retrading. I don’t want that reputation and you shouldn’t either.

Rule of Thumb

The rule of thumb is that you should make your offer based on what was seen in the initial tour. Things that weren’t seen but showed up in the inspection are fair-game for renegotiation. I didn’t do this. Maybe I should have, but I saw so little of the building I couldn’t give a coherent ask without making it low enough to protect myself.

You might say, “Just go back and give them time to give 24 hours notice.” I could do that, but there is an expense in time and money for me to do another tour. I wanted the seller to give me some indication that they understood there was a problem in their tour. They ended up shutting the door, and I didn’t have the expense of going back there.

Too bad, but there are so many properties out there that it’s stupid to stress out about one. If they don’t want to work with a buyer on the initial visit, then they aren’t very serious about making a sale, and I don’t want to waste my time on that type of seller. They won’t be interested in making a deal – just getting the best price. Good for them if they have the money to continue operating at a deficit. It seems like a great position to be in. For the rest of us, when we put something on the market, we need to be prepared to negotiate. Let’s move on to the next one.

Dr. Equity